The Orchestration of an Inmmune Response Unrehearsed Melanoma..Jim Breitfeller

The Orchestration of an Inmmune Response Unrehearsed

In 2006, after two fail attempts (Interferon and Dacarbazine with Patrin) to stop the progression of my melanoma, I was able try CTLA-4 Blockage. It was one of my first choices, but due to protocol, I had to try the FDA approved therapy first. I had researched this monoclonal antibody. On 10-24-2005 when I was first diagnosed with melanoma, I contacted Dr. Luis H. Camacho who was currently at MD Anderson.

Subject: Paper on Antitumor Activity

“Luis Camacho, My name is Jim Breitfeller and I have recently been diagnosed with melanoma will need some sort of Ontological therapy after my surgery. I ran across an abstract of yours (Antitumor activity in Melanoma and anti-self responses in Phase 1 trials with the anti-Cyctotoxic T Lymphocyte-Associated Antigen 4 Monoclonal Antibody CP-675,206) in the Journal of Clinical Oncology. Is it possible to get a copy of your paper? It can be emailed to the address below.”

Camacho response:

Dear James,

Thank you for your note. The CTLA4 antibodies in melanoma are currently under development and completing the approval process with the FDA (Phase II and Phase III). The overall response rates in my mind will be near 20-30% with a good number of patients attaining long term remissions. However, none of the programs are currently oriented to patients rendered NED (Stage III or IV). They are in fact for patients with advanced disease. From your brief introduction, I think your best options are to obtain an HLA typification and go for an adjuvant trial.

Please feel free to page me if you need further information. Pager is 713.404-5319
Best,

Luis

CP-675,206, a novel monoclonal antibody, enlists the immune system to fight advanced melanoma

Some Positive Test results of the CTLA-4

"Early testing of an experimental human monoclonal antibody showed a striking benefit in patients with advanced melanoma, say researchers at The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, who presented their findings at the annual meeting of the American Society of Clinical Oncology. Of 39 patients given a single injection of CP-675,206 (known as CP-675), tumors disappeared in three patients, shrunk in a fourth patient, and cancer stopped growing in five other patients. These responses have remained since their initial treatment, which ranged from 13 to 28 months ago.

Most of the patients in the trial had advanced melanoma, which has a median survival of less than a year, says the study's principal investigator, Luis Camacho, M.D., MPH, assistant professor in the Department of Melanoma Medical Oncology.

"We were very pleasantly surprised to find such objective antitumor responses in a Phase I clinical trial, which is designed to find the ideal dose and to look for side effects," says Camacho. "These results are very early, but they are encouraging to us because there are no good agents available to treat melanoma once it has spread."

Source: Laura Sussman from (ASCO) American Society of Clinical Oncology

At the time of the request, I was not at the correct stage but I knew that this might be the path of the future. I did contact him and we discussed my options at that time. I was just learning the ropes.

On 9/3/06 I contacted Dr. Rosenberg just in case I needed a back up plan if the CTLA-4 blockage did not work. At that time I did not know I was the wrong HLA-02 type for Rosenberg’s trials.

“I am Contacting Dr. Steven A. Rosenberg at the National Cancer Institute in Bethesda, Maryland.

He is the lead the researcher on the Gene Therapy Trials.
Log onto the CBS website for the story!!!!!!
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2006/08/31/health/main1955526.shtml
The research team recently applied to the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to try the new cells in about 100 patients. The FDA is expected to respond to the request by mid-September.

Dr. Rosenberg, I just got the news of your Gene Therapy Experiments. The initial results look somewhat promising. I applauded you and your team for making great strides in the cure for melanoma cancer.

I am a cancer patient (48 yrs. old) under the care of Dr. John Kirkwood at the Hillman Cancer Center at the University of Pittsburgh. I have gone through a wide incision, lymph nodes removal, Interferon therapy, and Dicarbazine therapy without success. I am presently on track to start a clinical trial with CTLA-4 monoclonal antibodies September 13, 2006. I have some tumors on my right side of my back and some in each lobe of my lungs. I would like to be considered for your next round of Gene Therapy in the coming months if I have no response to the CTLA-4 treatment. Please let me know if you would need a copy of my medical records to date.

Thanks again for the great work you are doing and I hope to hear from you in the near future.

Best Regards,

Jim Breitfeller

On 9/5/06 I received a call from Dr. Rosenberg’s office this morning while I was at Dr. Marino’s office. Kathy Morton (Research Nurse) contacted me by phone and asked a few questions about my health. She went on to say if I go with the CTLA-4 therapy, it would take about 2 months to washout before I could try the Gene Therapy. They would also have to do a colon biopsy to check the colon for any adverse conditions from the CTLA_4. She then gave me her direct phone number if I want to pursue the gene therapy at a later date.

So, on 9/13/06 (day 1)I had my first and only infusion of anti-CTLA-4 monoclonal antibodies. This was done as an outpatient procedure. Anti-CTLA4 monoclonal antibodies block the ability of CTLA4 to down-regulate T cell proliferation. The theory behind this therapy is that by decreasing the inhibitory signal, there will be a subsequent increase in the number of activated T-cells available, to improve the ability of the T-cells to recognize melanoma cells as non-self.

Before we can go any further, we need to know the clinical pharmacokinetics (pk)of anti-CTLA-4 monoclonal antibodies. Base on published papers, the predicted half-live of the antibody is around 3 weeks.11 This means your body will eliminate half the dose that was infused in you in about 21days. So, in 42 days or there about, the drug is completely gone from your system.

I started my CTLA-4 treatment at 9:15 am at 100 ml/hr and I had 500 mls hanging on my rack (Miss Daisy). I call the rack Miss Daisy because I have to take it with me where ever I go which includes the bathroom. I am driving Miss Daisy!! This will take us to 3:15 pm and then they draw blood for a pk study an hour later. So, we won’t get out until about 4:30 pm and home until 10:00 pm.

Day 7-9/19/06 “Along with the fatigue, my muscles ache like they have lactic acid in them”. Is this an indication of something? All immune cells begin as immature stem cells in the bone marrow.

Day 15 -9/27/06 about half the CTLA-4 antibodies are depleted. It appears that the CTLA-4 has stimulated my immune system. In the pass week, I noticed that there was redness around the area where my tumors are located. Also it is becoming quite tender in that area. This is Great news!!!!! It appears that the treatment my have kick started my immune system. The only way we will know for sure is another CT scan. That is not scheduled until November 23rd.

I sure hope this isn’t a false positive. Anyway, they gave me an antibiotic just in case it is an infection.

This inflammatory response provides a third signal that acts directly on T cells, referred to as the “danger signal”. “This signal was found to optimally activate TH1 differentiation and lead to clonal expansion of T cells12.

With this clonal expansion of the T cells and the secretion of IL-2, The Immune system is gearing up to make an assault on the foreign invaders, the tumors.

In 1988, a paper was published Autologous Tumor Specific Cytotoxic Lymphocytes in the Infiltrate of Human Metastatic Melanomas Activation by Interleukin 2 and Autologous Tumor Cells, and Involvement of the T Cell Receptor by Itoh and Colleagues.4

In their studies, they propagated (TILs) Tumor infiltrate lymphocytes cells from 12 Metastatic Melanoma patients. They preformed kinetic growth studies in IL-2 and even broke it down three Surface markers (CD3,CD4 and CD8). The results are as follows:

The average maximum propagation was 43 days. (N=12)
The average maximum propagation for (lung, Axilla) was 40 days (n=3)
The average maximum propagation for (CD3) was 78 +/- 11 days (n=12)
The average maximum propagation for (CD4) was 33 +/- 10 days (n=12)
The average maximum propagation for CD4 (lung, Axilla) was 26 days (n=3)
The average maximum propagation for (CD8) was 49 +/- 17 days (n=12)
The average maximum propagation for CD8 (lung, Axilla) was 57 days (n=3)

Base on the above data, it would take about 49 days for my activated T cells to reach maximum propagation.

4. Itoh, K; Platsoucas, CD; Balch, CM
Autologous Tumor Specific Cytotoxic Lymphocytes in the Infiltrate of Human Metastatic Melanomas Activation by Interleukin 2 and Autologous Tumor Cells, and Involvement of the T Cell Receptor [published J . Exp. MED. The Rockefeller University Press. 1988 Oct 1; Vol 168 October 1988 1419-1441
http://jem.rupress.org/cgi/reprint/168/4/1419.pdf


11. H. F. Wang1, J. M. Lovering1, R. M. Shepard1, D. Zhang2, T. A. Smolarek1, J. W. Findlay3 1Pfizer Inc, 2FDA, 3Gilead Sciences Inc; Pharmacokinetics of Tremelimumab, a Cytotoxic T Lymphocyte-Associated Antigen 4 (Ctla4) Blocking Monoclonal Antibody, in Nonhuman Primates
http://www.aapsj.org/abstracts/NBC_2008/NBC08-000658.PDF

12. Holger N. Lode,1 Rong Xiang,1 Ursula Pertl,1 Elisabeth Förster,2 Stephen P. Schoenberger,3 Stephen D. Gillies,4 and Ralph A. Reisfeld1; 1The Scripps Research Institute, Department of Immunology, La Jolla, California, USA2University Children’s Hospital Vienna, Vienna, Austria3La Jolla Institute for Allergy and Immunology, Division of Immune Regulation, San Diego, California, USA4Lexigen Pharmaceuticals Corp., Lexington, Massachusetts, USA Melanoma immunotherapy by targeted IL-2 depends on CD4+ T-cell help mediated by CD40/CD40L interaction; J Clin Invest. 2000 June 1; 105(11): 1623–1630. doi: 10.1172/JCI9177 http://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/articlerender.fcgi?artid=300854#B13#B13



To be continued!!!!!!



Jimmy B